Nykaa’s Fashion Struggles Amid Beauty Segment Growth: Can It Strike the Right Balance?
Nykaa, one of India’s leading beauty and lifestyle e-commerce platforms, continues to enjoy strong momentum in its beauty and personal care (BPC) segment, driven by high customer loyalty, strong gross merchandise value (GMV) growth, and a dominant market position. However, its fashion vertical has not mirrored this success, facing several operational and strategic challenges.
While beauty remains Nykaa’s core strength—fueled by high repeat purchase rates, organic discovery, and a well-established premium brand image—its fashion business is still finding its footing. The segment has underperformed in comparison, impacted by lower customer stickiness, fierce competition, and slimmer profit margins.
One of the biggest hurdles for Nykaa Fashion is the lack of high repeat rates. Unlike beauty products, which are replenished regularly, fashion items are bought less frequently, making customer retention and lifetime value lower. Additionally, organic discovery, which plays a crucial role in beauty sales through search, reviews, and influencer marketing, is more difficult to replicate in fashion, where brand loyalty is often fragmented and trends change quickly.
The company also grapples with higher logistics and return costs in the fashion category. Fashion products tend to have higher return rates compared to beauty items, leading to increased operational expenses. Moreover, unlike beauty—which enjoys higher margins, especially in premium segments—fashion is often a margin-thin business, particularly when competing with giants like Myntra, Ajio, and Amazon Fashion.
In response, Nykaa is cautiously tweaking its fashion strategy. The company is moving towards a marketplace model, which reduces inventory risk and optimizes fulfillment costs. It is also focusing on better brand partnerships, onboarding premium and niche labels to differentiate itself from other fashion players in the market.
Despite these steps, Nykaa must tread carefully to avoid diluting its premium positioning in beauty, which is its biggest competitive advantage. The brand has built a strong reputation as a trusted, quality-first destination for beauty and personal care products. If the fashion segment is not aligned with the same level of quality and customer experience, it could confuse consumers and weaken brand equity.
Industry experts suggest that for Nykaa Fashion to succeed, it must find a unique identity—perhaps focusing on curated, premium, and sustainable fashion choices that appeal to its existing beauty customer base. By integrating fashion in a way that complements its beauty offerings, Nykaa could eventually create a seamless lifestyle ecosystem.
As the company continues to invest in building its fashion vertical, balancing growth without compromising brand value will be key. The fashion segment presents a large market opportunity, but requires careful execution, better unit economics, and distinct positioning to replicate the success of Nykaa’s beauty arm.
![Snitch Launches 60-Minute Apparel Delivery: Redefining Fast Fashion with a City-First Quick Commerce Strategy]({"jaw_blog-16_9-small":{"file":"https:\/\/brandzmagazine.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/10\/Brand-Magzine-18-170x213.jpg","width":170,"filesize":11824},"jaw_blog-16_9-middle":{"file":"https:\/\/brandzmagazine.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/10\/Brand-Magzine-18-270x338.jpg","width":270,"filesize":23046},"jaw_blog-16_9":{"file":"https:\/\/brandzmagazine.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/10\/Brand-Magzine-18-475x594.jpg","width":475,"filesize":51750}})
![Zerodha to Enable US Stock Investments via GIFT City by Next Quarter: A New Era for Indian Retail Investors]({"jaw_blog-16_9-small":{"file":"https:\/\/brandzmagazine.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/10\/Ceo-India-170x213.jpg","width":170,"filesize":11970},"jaw_blog-16_9-middle":{"file":"https:\/\/brandzmagazine.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/10\/Ceo-India-270x338.jpg","width":270,"filesize":24048},"jaw_blog-16_9":{"file":"https:\/\/brandzmagazine.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/10\/Ceo-India-475x594.jpg","width":475,"filesize":55254}})
![IPO-Bound Lenskart Swings to Profit in Q1 FY26 with INR 61.2 Cr Net Gain, Revenue Jumps 25% YoY]({"jaw_blog-16_9-small":{"file":"https:\/\/brandzmagazine.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/10\/Brand-Magzine-17-170x213.jpg","width":170,"filesize":11551},"jaw_blog-16_9-middle":{"file":"https:\/\/brandzmagazine.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/10\/Brand-Magzine-17-270x338.jpg","width":270,"filesize":23711},"jaw_blog-16_9":{"file":"https:\/\/brandzmagazine.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/10\/Brand-Magzine-17-475x594.jpg","width":475,"filesize":54042}})